Monday, February 25, 2013

Vote the Best Summary



Students of 2nd batxillerat are going to vote which is the best summary written by students of 4 ESO.

We have been studying in 4th  ESO the layout of a summary in order to know how to synthesize a large text and students of 2n Batx, as they are experts in this type of writing, they will easily recognize the best one, leaving a comment of their opinion.

9 comments:

  1. After reading all the summaries from "The history of rubbish" by 4 ESO B, I've decided to choose summary number 6; and these are my reasons:

    First of all, it's structured into paragraphs, and that's EXTREMELY important because makes the reading more fluent, as there's a paragraph for the introduction, another one to explain all the content and the last one to do a small conclusion.

    It's also important to say that the information is well-organized so you can easly know what are they talking about in each moment.

    That's basically what made me choose summary number six!

    Andrea Corvo Garcia
    2n batx. humanístic

    ReplyDelete
  2. Now that I have read all the texts that the pupils of 4th ESO b have written, I have chosen the Summary number 4, and my reasons are:

    Because the text follows the structure of Introduction, explanation and conclusion, therefore there are paragraph

    Moreover, all the information of the text presents a good structure and organization.

    Marta Fernández Pons
    2n Batxillerat Humanístic

    ReplyDelete
  3. After reading all the summers of 4 ESO B, I decide that the best summary is the fifth.

    I decide this because is the only summary that give me a perspective of the years that happens all that is telling me. I mean that other summaries don’t tell me dates and it makes me feel disoriented. All summaries give me the same information and I decide that the fifth is the best because it differs from the other for this.

    On the other hand, all the summaries are good because they are similar and send us the same information, they are so good and really interesting.

    Mar Aguayo Florit
    2n Batx CCSS

    ReplyDelete
  4. It has been a bit difficult for me to choose the best summary of 4 ESO A, because Summary 1 and summary 3 were both very good, but after analysing the structure more, I have decided that Summary 1 is the best.

    To justify my choice I have realized that summary 1 is well structured, with an introduccion at first, then the statement of the facts and finally the conclusion.
    Furthermore the grammar it's quite good and the summary has its sense.
    Finally, just say that it's well summarized, because it's simple and very schematized.

    Carla Edo Pugès
    2n Batxillerat Científic

    ReplyDelete
  5. After i have read all the summeries that pupils on 4th ESO have done , I belive that the best Summery is number 6, there are diferent reasons that makes me feel confident whith my elction and there are:

    - The structure , summery number 6 have a ordenated and clear structure ( introductions,paragraph and conclusion)

    - The puntuation, the summery that i have chosen is the best in punctioation marks, makes the text more clear.

    Moreover there are in summery number 6 a very low number of grammar and vocabulary mistakes so in my opinion it is the best.

    Oriol Arechinolaza
    2 de Batxillerat Social

    ReplyDelete
  6. After reading the sumaries about "The history of rubbish" written by 4 ESO A, I have chosen the summari 1.

    I think that the summary I have chosen is the best because it is divided in paragraph and it has introduction and conclusion.

    There is another summary with paragraph, summary 3, but some of them are a bit short.

    For these reasons I think that summary 1 must be the winner.

    Helena Carbonero Navarro
    2n Batx A

    ReplyDelete
  7. Before reading the first thing that I have done is look at the structure of all texts of 4th ESO B, because is very important to have an introduction, then they have to explain all they want, and finally a short conclusion.

    The sixth text was the easier to read because uses the correct vocabulary and the correct structure, and that's why I think that's the best.

    Edu Combas Oller.
    2n Batxillerat Social.

    ReplyDelete
  8. After read all the text of the students of 4th ESO A I have chosen the Summary number 1.
    I chose this because it have a good estructure, it have some paragraph, introduction and conclution, and a good organization.
    Moreover they use some conectors and the text is easy to undrestand
    Carlota Carbonero
    2n Batxillerat bio

    ReplyDelete
  9. I have read all the summaries and I have decided on one of them.

    At first I had problems to choose between number 1 and number 3. After reading another time I have chosen the summary number 1 because it's conclusion is better and I think is easier to read than number 3.

    For this reasons I prefer number 1 for the best summary.

    WELL DONE GUYS!

    Víctor Domingo Rodríguez
    2n Batx. Tecno

    ReplyDelete